Hey, so I with some of the recent posts on "The Sultan's Harem" I was inspired to make a tier list you can find here:
https://tiermaker.com/create/the-sultans-harem-characters-tier-list-18029952
Might as well also give my ranking of all the girls from worst to best:
9. Lela: By far the least developed and underwritten of all the girls. Her entire personality is just "I'm primitive African jungle woman™ who just wants to eat everything", who doesn't even have a date or restaurant event. Also, I can't be the only one to find some pretty bad racist connotations from how the only black character in the roster is unlocked after buying her as a fucking slave, and again, she is just a "primitive African jungle woman™". The later stages does give her something like a personality, trying to make her more assertive and bossy, but honestly I feel like she just needs way more content, if not a full rework.
8. Oracle: She has a cool design and her pure pear shaped body and weight stages look pretty good so far. But so far all we have of her is a glorified introduction. An interesting introduction for sure, setting up some plot hooks with Eyanna and maybe an arc of her being more social by being around the other ladies. But for now, she will remain in a low tier until her story gets expanded. Thankfully, the next update is dedicated to her, so hopefully version 0.7 will expand on her further.
7. Eyanna: She gets some points by being by far the fattest character and her stuffing scenes are nice, but the fact that she's the main character's own sister is a massive turn off, the scenes of the Sultan admiring her body being more creepy than anything for me (Look, I admit I'm into some weird shit, hence why I'm here on this site, but incest is not one of them).
6. Rileigh: The newest character to be introduced and frankly, she's not bad, but she ain't great either. Like, her events are fine, with only the later ones being ones I'd say are good outright, but so far her personality is pretty bare bones, and the fact that she's yet another pear shape in a game that already has THREE other Pear shaped ladies is kinda disappointing. I hope Live gives us a bit more diversity in body shapes with future characters.
5. Valerie: I have mixed feelings on Valerie, as one part of her is great and the other part I find lackluster. On the one hand, her weight stages are pretty good looking, especially since she's a belly girl (my favorite BBW body type) and her final stages of you feeding her are also really hot. But on the other hand, I feel like she's one of the two characters that suffer from the fact that there are little to no interactions between the ladies in the game. Valerie's whole character once she enters the harem is that she has trouble fitting in with the other girls, but we really only see one event showcasing this in any way with her fight with Yixing. I feel like there is a potentially great plot about her and Yixing become rivals fighting for your attention, but so far all we get of her struggles and insecurities is her just telling us everything. Pretty much the "show, don't tell" problem. Also, I find the way she is introduced in the game and her first few events to be genuinely disturbing. Like, she is imprisoned for no real wrongdoing (she killed those soldiers sure, but that's after we literally threaten her) and she is unwillingly force-fed until she breaks and becomes completely submissive. Like, couldn't there be any way to include her that wasn't so fucked up? Like, ok she ends genuinely liking it, but at the very least we couldn't we have had some kind of arc of her still being a little bitter and reluctant when being included in the harem and then have her mellow out? Idk, I still think she's fine overall for now, but there are ways for her character to be far more interesting than she is now.