My only rule is you have to post the same amount for each to keep it fair. You can also post something other than a model like a type of content or clip style.
Overrated:
Violet James - Killer body, just an overwhelmingly massive slab of fat, but I think her videos are so repetitive. Just years and years of endless monotone fat chats and the same belly rub. The dynamic she had with Ivy was awesome but she got boring when she went out on her own. Never even showed her tits if I remember correctly.
Mochii - More of a circus sideshow than a fetish model. She's not particularly attractive, has zero charisma on camera, and frankly isn't even THAT fat. Yes it was amusing watching her speedrun her health into the ground but beyond that I never got her appeal and I don't know what her fans on here are still holding on to.
Lady Sublime - Ugh, this one brings me no pleasure. She's perfect on paper - 6 feet tall, 500 pounds (I think she embellishes the weight a bit but I'm willing to play ball), hotter than hell, well-spoken. And yet her content bores me to tears; she's almost too icy and composed for me, like everything she says is super rehearsed.
Underrated:
Cookie BBW - Something about this girl drives me absolutely wild lol. The girl next door vibe, her cute little accent, massive voluptuous curves. There's something candid and down to earth about her content, like she's giving you a secret glimpse into the pervy shit she does behind closed doors. There's something deeply erotic about a woman who looks like she holds down an office job when she's not busy stuffing herself to the brim with pizza and masturbating on camera.
Pleasantly Plump - I think she gets some credit but not nearly enough IMO. One of my favorite blob girls ever and a rare case of someone who sells the shit out of the extreme weight gain fantasy; I'm aware she was a real deal phone sex operator at one point so she may just be a good actress, but I always got the sense she enjoyed what she was doing. That goes a long way for me. Also looks hot as hell wearing a pig nose which is not usually my thing, but if the shoe fits...
Sasha - I think the tide is finally turning for Sasha since a lot of her peers have slowed down or retired, but I want to give the girl her flowers. She's been quietly pumping out great, varied content for years, all while doubling her body weight, keeping OF and clip prices reasonable and being generally accessible to fans - I've been in some of her livestreams and they're always a blast. Plus have you seen her?? She looks better now than when she was in her 20s. The only real knock on her is she didn't come into her own until leaving Big Cuties, but you could say that for a lot of models.